Buy for
$7.27
(6 items)

Release date: 24 April 1998
Style: Power metal

Rating:

8.8 | 1052 votes

Owners:

1427 have it
109 want it


01. War Of Wrath
02. Into The Storm
03. Lammoth
04. Nightfall
05. The Minstrel
06. The Curse Of Feanor
07. Captured
08. Blood Tears
09. Mirror Mirror
10. Face The Truth
11. Noldor (Dead Winter Reigns)
12. Battle Of Sudden Flame
13. Time Stands Still (At The Iron Hill)
14. The Dark Elf
15. Thorn
16. The Eldar
17. Nom The Wise
18. When Sorrow Sang
19. Out On The Water
20. The Steadfast
21. A Dark Passage
22. Final Chapter (Thus Ends...)
23. Nightfall [orchestral version, Japanese bonus]
24. A Dark Passage [instrumental version, Japanese bonus]
25. Harvest Of Sorrow [remastered edition bonus]

Top 20 albums of 1998: 6
Top 200 albums of all time: 95

Reviews (2)
Lyrics (21)

Guest review by
Storchillarn

Rating:
9.2
Power Metal and fantasy - dragons, magic and short, bearded fellows - have been walking hand in hand almost since the creation of the genre. Blind Guardian has strengthened this connection since their first album. Ten years after their initial release the genre-defining group returns with one of their most ambitious projects ever: a concept album based on the epic "Silmarillion" by J.R.R. Tolkien, one of the bands biggest influences. The result? Have they possibly managed to make something memorable and, most importantly, metal of the literary work? Hang on for the answer.

Read more ››
published 01.07.2007 | Comments (18)

Guest review by
Ernis

Rating:
7.7
Blind Guardian is an absolute star of Power Metal and their 1998 release 'Nightfall In Middle-Earth' is a monolithic work. Using the expression "left a mark" isn't enough. Of course this album has left a mark upon all who have listened to it and left a mark in the history of Power Metal and metal in general. And also literature, all in all, being like an asteroid leaving a crater.

Read more ››
published 01.10.2007 | Comments (12)

Found in 54 lists
Top lists

Fredd A Half-Assed List of Fredd's Favouritest Bunch of Albuns  | #43
qlacs Stuff That Makes You Fly To Another World! (almost like drugs)  | #4
scapeplan Scapeplan's Top 50 Albums Of All Time  | #7
Lit. Bibliophilia: Metal For Bookworms  | #8
Spirit Molecule You Wouldn't Know What Good Art Is If It Hit You In The Face  | #42
Dark†SymphonY A List Of Tolkien Themed Metal Albums  | #8
IronAngel Iron Recommends: A Metal Selection  | #57
Angel_Lament Best of the Best: Power Metal  | #18
More lists with this album (54) | Create a list! ››



Comments

‹‹ Back to the Albums
Comments: 28  
Users visited: 645  
Search this topic:  


Void Eater - 18.04.2011 at 09:28  
  This album makes me pissed off at the real world. We need elves in real life, goddamn it! Great album; Into the Storm, Mirror Mirror, and Nightfall all rank among my favorite power metal songs.
mikeprado30 - 24.04.2011 at 23:45  
Rating: 8 Their MOST overrated album, and also one of the MOST overrated albums in the music history, though for myself is a very nice album with very nice tracks (Mirror Mirror, When Sorrow Sang, Thorn, Time Stands Still, A Dark Passage, The Curse of Fëanor)
RavenKing - 25.04.2011 at 17:46  
 
Written by mikeprado30 on 24.04.2011 at 23:45

Their MOST overrated album, and also one of the MOST overrated albums in the music history


Totally agreed.
RedHawk - 26.04.2011 at 01:12  
Rating: 10 A masterpiece, one of my favorite metal albums.
Cynic Metalhead - 31.07.2011 at 02:02  
Rating: 10 This album has changed the definition of "EPIC"!
Guilherme - 29.09.2011 at 21:11  
  My favorite Album ever.
By far the best Blind Guardian album.

Quote:
Their MOST overrated album, and also one of the MOST overrated albums in the music history, though for myself is a very nice album with very nice tracks (Mirror Mirror, When Sorrow Sang, Thorn, Time Stands Still, A Dark Passage, The Curse of Fëanor)

Their MOST UNDERRATED.

Only 8.9, it deserves MORE THEN 10.

Btw, are you seriously telling me that you don't like Into the Storm and Nightfall? WTF? Maybe my 2 top Blind Guardian songs.

Every time I listen this album and remember the story of the book... it's just way too epic.
JÄY - 27.11.2011 at 08:00  
Rating: 8
Written by Guilherme on 29.09.2011 at 21:11

Their MOST UNDERRATED.

Only 8.9, it deserves MORE THEN 10.

Btw, are you seriously telling me that you don't like Into the Storm and Nightfall? WTF? Maybe my 2 top Blind Guardian songs.

Every time I listen this album and remember the story of the book... it's just way too epic.

It's just too damn soft....Into the Storm is an exeption, though
Void Eater - 27.11.2011 at 08:22  
 
Written by JÄY on 27.11.2011 at 08:00

It's just too damn soft....Into the Storm is an exeption, though

This is actually pretty hard hitting as far as symphonic power metal goes. Into The Storm, When Sorrow Sang, Time Stands Still, and Mirror Mirror all retain some of their older heaviness/some speed metal riffing.
JÄY - 27.11.2011 at 08:24  
Rating: 8
Written by Void Eater on 27.11.2011 at 08:22

Written by JÄY on 27.11.2011 at 08:00

It's just too damn soft....Into the Storm is an exeption, though

This is actually pretty hard hitting as far as symphonic power metal goes. Into The Storm, When Sorrow Sang, Time Stands Still, and Mirror Mirror all retain some of their older heaviness/some speed metal riffing.

4/24
Void Eater - 27.11.2011 at 08:27  
 
Written by JÄY on 27.11.2011 at 08:24

4/24

Well, half of those 24 aren't actual songs, so 4/12... But yeah, point taken. The Curse Of Feanor could be added into the heavier songs, making it 5/12 though...
Renard Solitaire - 29.01.2012 at 07:12  
  I noticed that a large number of metalheads on this forum are LoTR geeks. Could someone more knowledgeable than me in Metal create a comprehensive list of Tolkien/Lord of The Rings themed songs/albums? I know that the list should contain the whole discography of Blind Guardian, some songs by Iron Maiden, Nightwish, etc.
Zmaj Ognjeni Vuk - 29.01.2012 at 13:52  
Rating: 10
Written by Renard Solitaire on 29.01.2012 at 07:12

I noticed that a large number of metalheads on this forum are LoTR geeks. Could someone more knowledgeable than me in Metal create a comprehensive list of Tolkien/Lord of The Rings themed songs/albums? I know that the list should contain the whole discography of Blind Guardian, some songs by Iron Maiden, Nightwish, etc.

Here's a great one by an obscure NWOBHM band from the 80's called ARC:
Angelic Storm - 30.01.2012 at 04:51  
Rating: 7 I feel this is an overrated album, and is amongst Blind Guardian's weaker efforts overall. In the album's rare peaks such as "Mirror Mirror", "Nightfall", "The Eldar", and "When Sorrow Sang", the band show they are still adept at highly atmospheric, and at times, punishing power metal. But as a whole, the interludes seem unnecessary, and drag the album down. I also feel that many of the non-interlude songs are of a lesser quality than the band had shown on earlier (and indeed also on later,) albums.
RavenKing - 31.01.2012 at 00:49  
 
Written by Angelic Storm on 30.01.2012 at 04:51

I feel this is an overrated album, and is amongst Blind Guardian's weaker efforts overall. In the album's rare peaks such as "Mirror Mirror", "Nightfall", "The Eldar", and "When Sorrow Sang", the band show they are still adept at highly atmospheric, and at times, punishing power metal. But as a whole, the interludes seem unnecessary, and drag the album down. I also feel that many of the non-interlude songs are of a lesser quality than the band had shown on earlier (and indeed also on later,) albums.


You already know I agree about NIME being one of the weakest Blind Guardian album. I mentioned a few times how I believe this album is probably the most overrated Powermetal album of all time.
Angelic Storm - 31.01.2012 at 02:49  
Rating: 7
Written by RavenKing on 31.01.2012 at 00:49
You already know I agree about NIME being one of the weakest Blind Guardian album. I mentioned a few times how I believe this album is probably the most overrated Powermetal album of all time.


Yep, I am aware of that, and you likewise, already know how I feel about the album as we have discussed it on these boards before. As for most overrated power metal album of all time... I'd probably go along with that, as other much lauded power metal albums (such as the original 2 Helloween Keeper albums, Iced Earth's "Night Of The Stormrider", and Symphony X's "The Odyssey") are all pretty much deserving of the huge praise heaped upon them, whereas this album is not. Blind Guardian have made albums deserving of such praise, but not this one imo. When it's good, it's great, but those moments are fleeting, and the album contains far too much filler to be regarded as a classic.
RavenKing - 31.01.2012 at 04:17  
 
Written by Angelic Storm on 31.01.2012 at 02:49

As for most overrated power metal album of all time... I'd probably go along with that, as other much lauded power metal albums (such as the original 2 Helloween Keeper albums, Iced Earth's "Night Of The Stormrider", and Symphony X's "The Odyssey") are all pretty much deserving of the huge praise heaped upon them, whereas this album is not.


Agreed.
R'Vannith - 31.01.2012 at 05:48  
Rating: 7 This is one of those albums you have to listen to in full to really appreciate, with all the short bits and pieces scattered everywhere they build a nice atmosphere around the longer tracks. Unfortunate that the longer tracks don't really hold up to material like you find on 'Imaginations from the Other Side' or 'Tales from the Twilight World'.
Mountain King - 13.02.2012 at 11:45  
Rating: 7 Not more than a 7. But it's still way better than the horrible A Night At The Opera. Blind Guardian is too overrated, i don't get why they are the favorite power metal band of so much people. Even more overrated than Iced Earth...
Korah - 01.03.2012 at 21:54  
Rating: 7 Pretty good album, the best I heard from Blind Guardian.
mikeprado30 - 30.05.2012 at 07:25  
Rating: 8
Written by Mountain King on 13.02.2012 at 11:45

Not more than a 7. But it's still way better than the horrible A Night At The Opera. Blind Guardian is too overrated, i don't get why they are the favorite power metal band of so much people. Even more overrated than Iced Earth...

In my case is for the GREAT Hansi Kursch's voice. I love hugely his unique voice! Since I listened Valhalla in Tokyo Tales I fell in love with his voice forever And also 'cause (at least for myself) they have so much power in their early efforts, and even in his latter they don't lose quality (even when I miss their speedy days).

And TOTALLY disagree about calling "horrible" ANATO. For myself is their second best one. And every track is amazing for myself.
mikeprado30 - 30.05.2012 at 07:31  
Rating: 8
Written by Guilherme on 29.09.2011 at 21:11

My favorite Album ever.
By far the best Blind Guardian album.

Quote:
Their MOST overrated album, and also one of the MOST overrated albums in the music history, though for myself is a very nice album with very nice tracks (Mirror Mirror, When Sorrow Sang, Thorn, Time Stands Still, A Dark Passage, The Curse of Fëanor)

Their MOST UNDERRATED.

Only 8.9, it deserves MORE THEN 10.

Btw, are you seriously telling me that you don't like Into the Storm and Nightfall? WTF? Maybe my 2 top Blind Guardian songs.

Every time I listen this album and remember the story of the book... it's just way too epic.


Well, neither Into The Storm nor Nightfall impresses me so much. For my taste they are very weak (I love more the fastest BG side, songs like The Script for my Requiem, Valhalla, Born In A Mourning Hall, and some epic ones like And Then, Wheel of Time, Sacred Worlds, Curse My Name and others). I don't want to say those tracks from NIME are bad, just they don't get in my weak point like the ones I mentioned.

And for myself the best one is IMAGINATIONS FROM THE OTHER SIDE because it has the things I'm searching in the music. Aggresive music, fast tempo, catchy and charmful melodies and a GREAT voice (in IFTOS the Hansi's voice sounds more natural).

I've always said that the people overrates this album gets so because they sustain this point with their Tolkien fanatism.
Dentura - 11.07.2012 at 10:04  
Rating: 9 This album is absolutely amazing. This album is neck-to-neck with my other favorite BG album Night at the Opera!
LordHypnos - 06.10.2012 at 18:04  
Rating: 8 Great album, but too many fillers. They annoy me a lot!
JÄY - 10.11.2012 at 17:25  
Rating: 8
Written by yanivush147 on 10.11.2012 at 16:04

I will always prefer the first three speed metal albums.


Indeed, sir
Bad English - 01.01.2013 at 17:25  
Rating: 6 Last BG album .. secend lats in listen (since tribute to BG is not direct BG)
This album actualy onme song Mirror Mirror is wjhy I know this band I saw video when it was out and I thought is Marilion, then some yeras leither I found out and in 2004 starts my possession whity BG, same time when i net arived at my house , by by dial up, and real net came so, well about album its diferent there more epic tales, epic talkings how muisc, and muiscaly its most power metal (I dont remeber next one and I dont care, I know all who follow to this one is cheasy power and boring to my ears) so even this is also more power how previusly but still its OK
Rulatore - 27.02.2014 at 04:58  
Rating: 8 Their most overrated album, together with IFTOS. It has some all time classics (Time Stands Still (At The Iron Hill), Mirror Mirror, Nightfall, Into the Storm) and some good tunes (The curse of feanor, when the sorrow sang), the rest is some interludes and fillers
JÄY - 27.02.2014 at 05:24  
Rating: 8 I highly suggest listening to the Traveler's Guide remaster of this as the rhythm guitar can finally be heard!
deadone - 27.02.2014 at 05:27  
Rating: 9 I love this album. Phenomenal stuff.

Along with Imaginations From The Other Side, I would class this as their best.

Advertise on Metal Storm


Login or register to post here.



Similar topics

Forum Topic Similarity Started
Reviews Blind Guardian - Nightfall In Middle-Earth 7.5 01.10.2007 by Katatronik
Reviews Blind Guardian - Nightfall In Middle-Earth 7.5 01.07.2007 by Katatronik
Albums Blind Guardian - Guardians Of The Rings 7.5 22.08.2010 by SkaldfraNorden
Albums Blind Guardian - Follow The Blind 5.5 24.04.2011 by mikeprado30
Articles Blind Guardian in Melbourne, Australia 4.5 06.03.2007 by nb



Hits total: 13887 | This month: 145