03:47 - Darth Satanious ...out of place on purpose. It is like everything, some may find that something works and some may not. Fucking traffic control in the Shoutbox,
03:45 - !J.O.O.E.! True, but Battle Royale felt clearly rooted in satire, so they got away with it.
03:43 - Darth Satanious I think they wanted to put an interesting character with her, and I believe they succeded. Her place in Snow reminds me of that chick in the instructional video of Battle Royale. A weird, kind of eccentric character that feels...
03:42 - !J.O.O.E.! Which is ironic because she was the best part of the film, but the one element which didn't belong.
03:40 - !J.O.O.E.! [SPOILERS] It's like on one hand, you have the serious and tragic tone of the film where babies were eaten etc, then on the other hand you have the caricatured, designed for humour character of Swinton. Not compatible imo.
03:36 - !J.O.O.E.! I'd have been fine with that if the violence wasn't sandwiched between Tilder Swinton's comical Yorkshire accented dialogue. It didn't work and just seemed to confuse what the film wanted to be, and why it semi-failed in my eyes.
03:34 - Darth Satanious I see none of the things you say about Snowpiercer as flaws. If anything, I would have liked the violence to be less stylised and more raw, like normal people killing each other. But of course soldiers are meant toknow their shit.