05:35 - Fearmeister What I found interesting is that the people who think 10s are next to impossible have a buy-threshold of ~7.5, while the people who have no problem giving out 10s have a buy-threshold of ~8.5. Just a cool thing I noticed
05:24 - Fearmeister Yea, so you like 2 of the songs less. There are plenty of people who gave out 9s to albums where they liked 2 of the songs a bit less than the rest
05:20 - deadone It'd be a 9 if songs like Sacrifice or Heavens On Fire were better. It'd be a 10 if these were excellent. However despite it's score of 8, large chunks are still soul catching.
05:17 - Fearmeister Yea, and so do I. I can fucking sing, air guitar and air drum Black Metal (the album) from start to finish. If that's not evidence of a 10, idk what is
05:15 - deadone Actually you are applying my scoring to your thinking.. Also something can be soulcatching and imperfect - I like Venom FFS.
05:09 - Fearmeister Exactly, you can't have 'unused' numbers. To leave 10s empty is simply stating that there is a level beyond soul catching
05:07 - MetalDoomMaster I think it's easier to think of 10s as "best of the best" instead of perfect. By your rating standards, there shouldn't even be a 10 on the scale. There must be some of those 9s you like more than other 9s.
01. Inception, The Bleeding Skies 02. Pillars Of Serpents 03. If I Could Collapse The Masses 04. Fugue (A Revelation) 05. Requiem 06. Ember To Inferno 07. Ashes 08. To Burn The Eye 09. Falling To Grey 10. My Hatred 11. When All Light Dies 12. A View Of Burning Empires 13. Blinding Tears Will Break The Skies [bonus] 14. The Deceived [demo][bonus] 15. Demon [bonus]
01. The End Of Everything 02. Rain 03. Pull Harder On The Strings Of Your Martyr 04. Drowned And Torn Asunder 05. Ascendancy 06. A Gunshot To The Head Of Trepidation 07. Like Light To Flies 08. Dying In Your Arms 09. The Deceived 10. Suffocating Sight 11. Departure 12. Declaration 13. Blinding Tears Will Break The Skies [2006 reedit bonus] 14. Washing Away Me In The Tides [2006 reedit bonus] 15. Master Of Puppets [Metallica cover][2006 reedit bonus] 16. Dying In Your Arms [video mix][2006 reedit bonus]
01. Ignition 02. Detonation 03. Entrance Of The Conflagration 04. Anthem (We Are The Fire) 05. Unrepentant 06. And Sadness Will Sear 07. Becoming The Dragon 08. To The Rats 09. This World Can't Tear Us Apart 10. Tread The Floods 11. Contempt Breeds Contamination 12. The Rising 13. The Crusade
Disc I[CD] 01. Kirisute Gomen 02. Torn Between Scylla And Charybdis 03. Down From The Sky 04. Into The Mouth Of Hell We March 05. Throes Of Perdition 06. Insurrection 07. The Calamity 08. He Who Spawned The Furies 09. Of Prometheus And The Crucifix 10. Like Callisto To A Star In Heaven 11. Shogun 12. Poison, The Knife Or The Noose [Special Ltd. Edition bonus] 13. Upon The Shores [Special Ltd. Edition bonus] 14. Iron Maiden [Iron Maiden cover][Special Ltd. Edition bonus]
Disc II[DVD] + The Making Of Shogun + Shogun: The Riffs - Instructional Videos
Disc I[Standard Edition] 01. Capsizing The Sea 02. In Waves 03. Inception Of The End 04. Dusk Dismantled 05. Watch the World Burn 06. Black 07. A Skyline's Severance 08. Built to Fall 09. Caustic Are the Ties That Bind 10. Forsake Not The Dream 11. Chaos Reigns 12. Of All These Yesterdays 13. Leaving This World Behind
Disc I[Special Edition] 01. Capsizing The Sea 02. In Waves 03. Inception Of The End 04. Dusk Dismantled 05. Watch The World Burn 06. Black 07. A Skyline's Severance 08. Ensnare The Sun 09. Built To Fall 10. Caustic Are The Ties That Bind 11. Forsake Not The Dream 12. Drowning In Slow Motion 13. A Grey So Dark 14. Chaos Reigns 15. Of All These Yesterdays 16. Leaving This World Behind 17. Shattering The Skies Above 18. Slave New World [Sepultura cover]
Disc II[Special Edition bonus DVD] 01. In Waves [Live from Chapman Studios] 02. Black [Live from Chapman Studios] 03. Built to Fall [Live from Chapman Studios] 04. Watch the World Burn [Live from Chapman Studios] 05. The Deceived [Live from Chapman Studios] 06. Suffocating Sight [Live from Chapman Studios] 07. Down from the Sky [Live from Chapman Studios] 08. Ember to Inferno [Live from Chapman Studios] 09. In Waves [documentary] 10. In Waves [music video]
01. Brave This Storm 02. Vengeance Falls 03. Strife 04. No Way To Heal 05. To Believe 06. At The End Of This War 07. Through Blood And Dirt And Bone 08. Villainy Thrives 09. Incineration: The Broken World 10. Wake (The End Is Nigh) 11. No Hope For The Human Race [Deluxe Edition bonus] 12. As I Am Exploding [Deluxe Edition bonus] 13. Skulls...We Are 138 [Misfits cover][Deluxe Edition bonus] 14. Losing My Religion [R.E.M. cover][Japanese bonus]