Written by Guest on 12.05.2011 at 23:08

I like Teutonic Thrash more than the others. They've got a more "evil" edge to them in their music, in my opinion.

That's exactly my own opinion. I never liked the Bay Area Thrash at all.
Only American Thrash I like is early Slayer and it's not from Bay Area.

Written by Guest on 13.05.2011 at 11:26

Written by immortal83 on 13.05.2011 at 10:29

Sepultura's first albums are fucking great, but Brazilian Thrash scene? I don't know any other thrash band from Brazil right now. It's difficult to choose one option, but I think that Bay Area is the most famous and known because of Metallica. There are other bands without a scene like Coroner, Celtic Frost, Venom.... I vote for Bay Area (maybe LA) because of Metallica, Slayer , Megadeth.

Yeah I can't think of many Brazillian bands either. Sarcofago and Sepultura are the only ones that come to mind. I'm sure theres way more. They had quite a big Death/thrash scene.

Mutilator, Chakal, Executer, Korzus

How about Megadeth?

Written by Saeed_p on 13.05.2011 at 22:48

How about Megadeth?

Its Bay area

For me its hard I like all scenes but my fav bands come non from those Arthilery, Sabbat + old Arakain so I dont vote, but I enjoy all bands and scenes whats on list

Written by Bad English on 13.05.2011 at 22:59

Written by Saeed_p on 13.05.2011 at 22:48

How about Megadeth?

Its Bay area

Hopefully i voted for bay area because i like EXODUS.thx

Written by Guest on 13.05.2011 at 03:49

If I put MEGADETH, METALLICA and SLAYER in any scene, everyone would have voted for that scene!

And without mentioning them everybody would vote for the German scene, before i posted my 'controversial' post Teutonic scene had twice as much votes as bay area, now that Metallica and Megadeth are mentioned, things are set right again.. so, you should've just mentioned them from the beginning,

i mean, with old bastards holding phD in metal like Marcel and Bittercold, you should've guessed this would be mentioned

Written by Guest on 13.05.2011 at 03:49

If I put MEGADETH, METALLICA and SLAYER in any scene, everyone would have voted for that scene!

No

Written by BitterCOld on 13.05.2011 at 04:05

Written by Guest on 13.05.2011 at 03:49

If I put MEGADETH, METALLICA and SLAYER in any scene, everyone would have voted for that scene!

so your poll is fucking pointless then.

you intentionally omitted bands that were integral to scenes because it would influence voting? hell... why not list the Teutonic scene without 3 equally integral bands. suddenly you're left with, what? tankard?

Metallica was one of the key bands in the Bay Area scene, it was their pad everyone partied at. Omitting them to attempt to adjust the poll results just invalidates the question.

No. Let me get this straight. If a user, who doesn't have a good knowledge of thrash, gets into this poll and sees Metallica somewhere, he will vote for it. He will say:"Wow, if such a scene spawned an act like Metallica, then it must be the best" So I excluded those bands you would know even if you're not into thrash.

Written by Guest on 14.05.2011 at 01:48

No. Let me get this straight. If a user, who doesn't have a good knowledge of thrash, gets into this poll and sees Metallica somewhere, he will vote for it. He will say:"Wow, if such a scene spawned an act like Metallica, then it must be the best" So I excluded those bands you would know even if you're not into thrash.

i disagree. people don't read and will simply pick not the scene, but from the bands you list at the top.

so either list them all, or don't. omission is just an attempt on your part to steer votes.

but i still think it's a worthless poll. the Bay Area thing was one scene with a ton of bands that played and partied together. you're comparing one city against countries. the Bay Area was a legit scene. somehow i don't think Canada was a scene. Montreal might have had a scene. Calgary might have had a scene, but they aren't the same scene. are Sodom, Kreator, and Destruction all from the same city?

Bay Area wins buuut i still love my canadian bands :] lol Annihilator rules the world!!! *angry metal face*

German scene, still rockin today.
Love thrash, not fan of metallica (had to say it)

Written by RavenKing on 13.05.2011 at 21:00

Written by Guest on 13.05.2011 at 11:26

Written by immortal83 on 13.05.2011 at 10:29

Sepultura's first albums are fucking great, but Brazilian Thrash scene? I don't know any other thrash band from Brazil right now. It's difficult to choose one option, but I think that Bay Area is the most famous and known because of Metallica. There are other bands without a scene like Coroner, Celtic Frost, Venom.... I vote for Bay Area (maybe LA) because of Metallica, Slayer , Megadeth.

Yeah I can't think of many Brazillian bands either. Sarcofago and Sepultura are the only ones that come to mind. I'm sure theres way more. They had quite a big Death/thrash scene.

Mutilator, Chakal, Executer, Korzus

If you dig you can find a lot of bands from anywhere, but I don't think in a Brazilian thrash scene. Are all of them of the same period? I could say that there is a Thrash scene in Sweden with The Haunted, Meshuggah, The Crown,.... will you agree?

I voted for "Brazilian Thrash (Old Sepultura)

I would vote all of them,because every scene gave us some great bands,i can't really choose between Testament,Kreator,Annihilator and Sepultura,love them all

Written by Razorback on 20.05.2011 at 14:56

I would vote all of them,because every scene gave us some great bands,i can't really choose between Testament,Kreator,Annihilator and Sepultura,love them all

Right there with ya man, I love me some amd exodus, but metal is metal

Gotta say Teutonic. Germany is one of the best thrash countries in the world. And Kreator, Sodom, and Destruction are some of my favorite thrash bands of all time! I also love Testament and Sepultura, but the Teutonic thrash scene produced more high quality bands than any other scene in the poll.

I'm not sure people actually understand the concept of "scene"...

I just voted East Coast Thrash, because of the bands mentioned there. Overkill is probably my favourite thrash band. They have a lot of awesome bands though.

Voted east coast too but you failed to mention another important thrash band that hails from New York City: Prong

Written by BitterCOld on 14.05.2011 at 01:57

Written by Guest on 14.05.2011 at 01:48

No. Let me get this straight. If a user, who doesn't have a good knowledge of thrash, gets into this poll and sees Metallica somewhere, he will vote for it. He will say:"Wow, if such a scene spawned an act like Metallica, then it must be the best" So I excluded those bands you would know even if you're not into thrash.

i disagree. people don't read and will simply pick not the scene, but from the bands you list at the top.

so either list them all, or don't. omission is just an attempt on your part to steer votes.

but i still think it's a worthless poll. the Bay Area thing was one scene with a ton of bands that played and partied together. you're comparing one city against countries. the Bay Area was a legit scene. somehow i don't think Canada was a scene. Montreal might have had a scene. Calgary might have had a scene, but they aren't the same scene. are Sodom, Kreator, and Destruction all from the same city?

I can confirm that Canada does not have a "thrash scene" just a few thrash bands that got big. Annihilator and Voivod were from separate cities, which were drastically different, culturally and musically. The only real "scene" associated with a specific metal movement is the Quebec death metal scene. Granted, places like Toronto, Vancouver & Calgary may have strong metal scenes, but they are fairly mixed, you're not going to find a specific movement from one city, Calgary has a bit more prog than anything else here, but not enough to be dubbed any sort of "prog scene".

I think perhaps the word he was looking for was "movement". If that's the case, I'd vote Teutonic. Still, this thread is silly. Brazilian thrash scene? With 1 band listed? If you wanted to curb votes a little, perhaps you should equal everything out a bit better.

I prefer the teutonic thrash metal scene, but even i love the thrash metal, and the have a lot differents things, but for me i prefer the teutonics!

I like all scenes, but I would prefer the Teutonic thrash scene with Kreator, Sodom, Destruction, Tankard, Assassin, Exumer and Necronomicon (the bands I just mentioned are the bands that I like the most within the Teutonic thrash scene).

Teutonic Thrash all the way.Kreator and Tankard are my favourite bands at the moment.Die with a beer in your hand:beer: