Where I live we where always one year after with everything. It probably was difficult getting albums distributed to us so 1994 was very much Icon for me.
01. With Hearts Toward None I 02. With Hearts Toward None II 03. With Hearts Toward None III 04. With Hearts Toward None IV 05. With Hearts Toward None V 06. With Hearts Toward None VI 07. With Hearts Toward None VII
Mgła is one of the greatly hyped black metal bands of our time (and quite rightly so), playing music that is at the same time melodic, as well as crushingly dark and evil. The duo from Poland became well-known in underground circles with its early EPs and the acclaimed debut album, Groza. However, the band had its - relatively speaking - big break in 2012 with the release of the second full-length studio album, With Hearts Toward None.
The real standout of the album is its sheer energy! This is not by-the-numbers, soulless modern black metal: there is a fiery passion here that is ignited throughout the entire album.
Listened to about half the album on youtube and I'm having trouble understanding why this the 4th highest rated album on RYM. I'm finding it extremely repetitive and mediocre at the very best of times.
The amount of praise this is getting (outside of MS anyway) is patently absurd. I'm gonna have to give this another listen, just to be sure this is the bland slab of average I think it is.
Written by Guest on 05.04.2012 at 06:13 The amount of praise this is getting (outside of MS anyway) is patently absurd. I'm gonna have to give this another listen, just to be sure this is the bland slab of average I think it is.
I'm gonna have to give this a listen to see what I think. 2012 is passing me by with all these releases and part of me doesn't even really care. There just seems to be fewer and fewer releases I'm interested in.
Losing interest in metal, music, or just new stuff?
----
"Wise men talk because they have something to say; fools because they have to say something."
I'm gonna have to give this a listen to see what I think. 2012 is passing me by with all these releases and part of me doesn't even really care. There just seems to be fewer and fewer releases I'm interested in.
Losing interest in metal, music, or just new stuff?
To be honest it took me 3 months till I started checking out 2012 releases. I go through phases of old and new really. You'll probably get a spurt of trying out new stuff at some point I would imagine. To be honest though, you aren't missing a great deal from 2012.
Completed another spin and am bumping this up to a 6.5 just because it's well constructed and tight but it's still ultimately very repetitive (and not in the good psychedelic, droning way).
Destined to become the overrated black metal album of the year I would think.
Only just started the fourth track but it's safe to say I'm going with at least a high seven/low eight on this.
So I don't love it... but I do think it's a lot better than you say, so balance isn't exactly destroyed.
I'd probably bump it up to a 7 if it hadn't been so hyped everywhere I looked. I just found as I was listening to it that it had very samey progressions and approaches on each song which irked me a bit.
Written by Guest on 07.04.2012 at 04:24 ...very samey progressions and approaches on each song which irked me a bit.
First thing I noticed. I'm halfway through now and honestly the overall structure from one song to another differs, at best, minimally. Being one who thoroughly enjoys simplicity and repetition in atmo-black metal, I totally dig it. But I can objectively look down on it for failing to venture into any kind of truly engaging territory.
And I completely fail to see the reason behind the hype. Like... it's a pretty awesome album, but what about it warrants any kind of special attention? No different than the slew of atmo-black albums I was throwing mid-8s to at the end of 2011. Good shit and fans of the genre should enjoy it, but even then it's not like we're being exposed to anything different.
----
"Wise men talk because they have something to say; fools because they have to say something."
I suppose I can see why everyone's complaining about it not breaking any new ground. That said, this is probably one of the most enjoyable albums I've listened to this year. It's not that I'm convinced Mgla is the future of black metal or anything, but for lack of a more intelligent thought this album just exudes a kind of passion and vitality I never get out of straight black metal like this. There's something about the melodies that are so emotionally absorbing, and it makes defending this album frustrating because it no doubt is repetitive and largely unwilling to break a whole lot of new ground. I guess an issue like that doesn't bother me at all when the execution is so damned tasty
I don't mind the repetitiveness, I actually like it. And there is progression in some songs (even though ultimately the structure might be similar). But the main thing that draws me to this album is the atmosphere and rawness.
Moments like the beginning of this song (0:00 - 2:15) give me goosebumps. Doesn't happen that often anymore...
First deep incursion into Mgla territory.... and it's epic !!! Till now just listened to a couple songs from previous albums thinking it was typical orthodox BM click-click-click-repetitiveness.
And it is repetitive, yes, but in an awesome way. It adds to the atmosphere playing those great riffs over and over again, and some of them together with the progressions are way too excellent. Vocals are very discernable too, and more rough yells than simple shrieks. Production is also the way modern BM should be done, not too clean yet updated sound with every instrument audible.
Hmmm quite late to the party, but glad I decided to check it out
First deep incursion into Mgla territory.... and it's epic !!! Till now just listened to a couple songs from previous albums thinking it was typical orthodox BM click-click-click-repetitiveness.
And it is repetitive, yes, but in an awesome way. It adds to the atmosphere playing those great riffs over and over again, and some of them together with the progressions are way too excellent. Vocals are very discernable too, and more rough yells than simple shrieks. Production is also the way modern BM should be done, not too clean yet updated sound with every instrument audible.
Hmmm quite late to the party, but glad I decided to check it out
I still think this is a really boring and repetitive (in a non-awesome way) album. Much prefer them when they sounded like this:
I'm only checking back catalogue now, but I don't see much difference (in the composition) if only for the production (grimmer for sho'). That song even starts in a very similar way than With Hearts Towards None I (and it's great too). Granted I might prefer the sound as it was on Further Down... and that Hearts... got an unnecessary praise considering the progression of the band (kvlt circles got all crazy over it), but it's one of the kinds of BM I can really appreciate, so all good for me !!
Man, I remember listening to this in late 2012 / early 2013 and not thinking it was anything special, but here we are years later and people I know are still going nuts over this band. Maybe I should give them another chance soon?
Man, I remember listening to this in late 2012 / early 2013 and not thinking it was anything special, but here we are years later and people I know are still going nuts over this band. Maybe I should give them another chance soon?
Nah... It's nothing special, really
----
"Aah! The cat turned into a cat!"
- Reimu Hakurei