‹‹ Back to the General metal forum Pages: 1 [2]
Posts: 35  
Users visited: 84  
Search this topic:  

The original post

Posted by on 03.08.2013 at 10:58
I really want to know how Metalstormers distinguish these three ? I'm not trying to compare them,but it's not easy to draw a certain line between them.

Page 2 of 2

Boxcar Willy
yr a kook

Posts: 7339

Age: 20
From: Canada

  12.08.2013 at 23:07
Little tardy to the party, but I do not see how Avantgarde and Post-metal are even near related.
forever bummed out

Posts: 3099

Age: 25
From: Australia

  13.08.2013 at 07:29
Post metal and avantgarde metal are experimental. As Uldreth said post metal is a derivation of post rock, which initially was quite experimental in its use of usual rock instrumentation but put to use in unusual song structures atypical of those found in rock. As I understand it was about stripping the genre down to its bare essentials or to its foundations which are the instruments and then rebuilding the structure from the ground up, writing songs that used rock instruments but sounded nothing like rock. To confuse things you might describe that as avantgarde in approach.

Post rock, and by extension post metal, was experimental and avantgarde initially and proved to be influential enough to spawn itself a genre of music. As bands that play post metal arise they can be generic and do little to further the style, their artistic motives having less to do with the same kind of inspiration which the likes of Isis or Neurosis had in establishing a set of characteristic elements which others have caught onto and attempted to replicate or imitate.

Post has more definite generic traits than avantgarde, vague as they are I suppose.

I think of avantgarde as less of a genre and more as a broad collective of innovative approaches which push the boundaries of particular metal subgenres and/or metal itself as a genre. These approaches usually come from a range of sounds, from playing around with death metal structures, black metal structures etc. You'll find some avantgarde bands imitating or borrowing the ideas and approaches of others which leads to a loose sense of a genre, or at least much looser and broader in scope than is largely the case with post metal.

Experimental metal, as has been said already isn't a genre, it's used to indicate that what a band plays and how they play it involves some sort of creative feature not used or infrequently used before.
Angel N.
Evil Butterfly

Posts: 2233
From: Germany

  11.11.2014 at 21:53
Written by Boxcar Willy on 12.08.2013 at 23:07

Little tardy to the party, but I do not see how Avantgarde and Post-metal are even near related.

I'm not sure, it came to my mind maybe because some bands that were tagged Avant garde were also tagged post metal, not sure really.
The Fangirl.

Posts: 210

Age: 23
From: Iran

  11.11.2014 at 22:52
I think Post Metal is born with combining Avantgarde and Sludge/Progressive so in some cases they can be related

Posts: 916

Age: 20
From: USA

  27.11.2014 at 07:35
Avant-garde metal and experimental metal are the same thing, avant-garde just has the connotation of being a bit weirder, and experimental is more often used as an adjective while avant-garde is more often used as a genre in it's own right. I think it should be self-explanatory what experimental metal is. Post-metal, meanwhile, is just post-rock fused with heavy metal, but often refers more specifically to the atmospheric sludge sound of Neurosis and Isis, but the confusion comes because for some reason experimental metal is sometimes used to refer to post-metal, probably because the first bands very much were experimental metal.

Advertise on Metal Storm
Pages: 1 [2]

Login or register to post here.

Similar topics

Forum Topic Similarity Started
General metal forum The Band that Invented Metal 6 01.06.2006 by Lupas
General metal forum Doom is/isnt an extreme metal genre 6 17.10.2009 by
General metal forum True Heavy Metal vs Punk Rock Poseurs 6 29.06.2014 by Ganondox
Extreme metal forum What is Black Metal nowadays? 5 09.02.2014 by Karlabos
General website discussion Hipster black metal tag on MS? 5 26.01.2016 by