Rating:
9.0
Anthrax - The Greater Of Two Evils [Compilation]
23 November 2004


01. Deathrider
02. Metal Thrashing Mad
03. Caught In A Mosh
04. A.I.R.
05. Among The Living
06. Keep It In The Family
07. Indians
08. Madhouse
09. Panic
10. I Am The Law
11. Belly Of The Beast
12. N.F.L.
13. Be All End All
14. Gung-Ho


In 2004 thrash began to make a resurgence. Veteran thrash bands came back with strong offerings (Death Angel "The Art of Dying" / Exodus "Tempo of the Damned") and others delivered their strongest offerings in years (Megadeth "The System Has Failed"). Younger acts (Merciless Death, Warbringer, Gamma Bomb, Evile, etc.) were surely planting the seeds that came to fruition on their first EP's and LP's that would be released a couple of years later.

Anthrax, along with a few other thrash veterans like Overkill and Slayer (don't bring up Metallica circa 2004), continued to release material into the new millennium after their glory days had long passed. Anthrax maintained some of their early momentum with "The Sound of White Noise" when Joey Belladonna was replaced by John Bush, but they began to fall out of favor with their fans shortly after. In 2003 Anthrax released their strongest offering in years with "We've Come for You All", which seemed to help get them back on track.

A lot of bands now re-record their strongest early material, which they may not be fairly compensated for in royalties. Anthrax did this in 2004 with "The Greater of Two Evils", but their approach did not seem like most others. Their effort here works well in a few distinct ways:

1. The Production - these songs were recorded over just two days and, as Scott Ian refers to them in the liner notes, sound "like a class five hurricane blowing through the room". The band has top notch equipment and a world class studio to give it a great sound, but the short recording period gives it that garage feel that most thrashers love.

2. The Songs -There is no need to talk much about the strength of the individual songs since what's here is basically a well represented "best of" collection of re-recorded songs. You surely have an Anthrax favorite or two that are not represented, but it is hard to argue with what is on here. These are tracks that were selected by the fans, which adds to the throwback appeal. If you stick around through the end of the final track ("Gung-Ho") you will be blessed with "Lone Justice", which is tagged to the end. Everything that is on here was originally released in the periods prior to John Bush taking over lead vocals. This is a plus (see point 3).

3. John Bush - John Bush was with Armored Saint prior to joining Anthrax. He is one of the most overlooked vocalists in heavy metal. His vocals are always powerful and he never has to reach out of his enormous range for a growl or a grunt to get his point across. Most people would agree that Anthrax's best material was written on their first 5 or 6 albums prior to his tenure with the band, but some of us would also agree that John Bush's voice on top of these songs adds to their power. This album is a must have for those people.

Sadly, after this album was recorded, Anthrax seemed to want to cash in on the renewed thrash craze that had built an even bigger head of steam. Thrash acts were being congratulated and rewarded for being "old school". Instead of working with the momentum of "We've Come for You All" and the eye opening aggressive thrash of "The Greater of Two Evils", Anthrax sacked John Bush and went "old school" with Joey Belladonna. Prior history and common sense predicted that this reunion would be short lived and Belladonna was soon again the ex-lead singer of Anthrax. John Bush wisely resisted offers to return and will soon release new material with Armored Saint. As for Anthrax, they tried getting Corey Taylor from Slipknot to join the band and have recently settled on the unknown Dan Nelson. They described his voice as "John Bush on steroids". Yeah whatever guys….if that makes you feel better.

This album really is "The Greater of Two Evils" (the greatness of John Bush and Anthrax's early material). Reviews factor in the work's originality and since this is previously released material it is hard to give it much of a grade there, but it is the only possible detraction in my opinion. A great recommendation for fans of old Anthrax, John Bush era Anthrax and Armored Saint.

Performance: 10
Songwriting: 10
Originality: 8
Production: 10


Band profile: Anthrax
Album: The Greater Of Two Evils


 


written by amerislave | 21.12.2008


Guest review disclaimer:
This is a guest review, which means it does not necessarily represent the point of view of the MS Staff.



Comments

‹‹ Back to the Reviews
Comments: 3  
Users visited: 54  
Search this topic:  


jupitreas - 21.12.2008 at 20:16  
Interesting review, although I would personally argue against the production being very good. Everything is brickwalled depriving the album of dynamic range, which happens to be why a lot of these songs worked so well in the first place (case in point - the famous drum break in the beginning of "Caught In A Mosh", which sounds painfully flat here). I actually really like this collection of re-recorded tracks; however, I find myself having to tweak the sound considerably with an amp/mixer combo before it sounds any good.
amerislave - 21.12.2008 at 20:46  
Written by jupitreas on 21.12.2008 at 20:16

Interesting review, although I would personally argue against the production being very good. Everything is brickwalled depriving the album of dynamic range, which happens to be why a lot of these songs worked so well in the first place (case in point - the famous drum break in the beginning of "Caught In A Mosh", which sounds painfully flat here). I actually really like this collection of re-recorded tracks; however, I find myself having to tweak the sound considerably with an amp/mixer combo before it sounds any good.


i understand your point....definitely valid, but i personally feel that the production is perfect for what they were trying to accomplish and that it adds to the feel.....old thrashers getting together to jam like they used to. the liner notes include a picture of friends and fans that were hanging around the studio while they were banging these tunes out over a couple of days, which is how the album feels (in a good way). who am i though? my favorite metallica album is "...and justice for all" .... so my production knowledge could be in question!
ajohns1 - 20.03.2013 at 05:32  
I love Anthrax with Joey and Bush, but I especially like Bush.....hahaha. All the classics sung by my favorite Anthrax singer is just pure gold. He really makes all the songs his own, but a few are better left to Joey, like: Madhouse and Indians.

Advertise on Metal Storm


Login or register to post here.



Similar topics

Forum Topic Similarity Started
Reviews Anthrax - Among The Living 5.5 07.08.2006 by Talvi
News Anthrax - Entering The Studio 4.5 13.08.2008 by
Albums Anthrax - I'm The Man 4.5 29.08.2010 by vezzy
Reviews Testament - The Gathering 4.5 01.01.2009 by BreadGod
Reviews Wolves In The Throne Room - Two Hunters 4 18.02.2011 by Himann



Hits total: 2687 | This month: 16