Rating:
7.2
Svartby - Riv, Hugg Och Bit
28 August 2009


01. Dvärgby
02. Trollkarlar Av Dvärgfolk
03. Dvärgars Bastu
04. Ölfrun
05. Ensam Ensling
06. Groda, Ryttare
07. Solens Ljus
08. Kvävande Gruvor
09. Regnbågen
10. Liv Eller Guld
11. Humus
12. Riv, Hugg Och Bit
13. Snubbar, Snubbar
14. Vinterkväll


In looking for some new folk bands to listen to I stumbled across the Russian band Svartby and decided to pursue their latest album: Riv, Hugg Och Bit. Why? Their Myspace had some pretty interesting songs that seemed to defy the growing clichés present in the ever stagnating folk metal genre. Unfortunately the experience is extremely hit or miss.

Svartby plays a type of folk metal very similar to Finntroll, with deep growls and an attempt at a sing-songy "polka" infusion. While clearly not a copycat it is an easy comparison that does not bode favorably for Svartby. Unlike Finntroll who have managed to make extremely fun songs a la "Trollhammeren" the music of Svartby on Riv, Hugg Och Bit is much more serious, serious meaning boring. Although Svartby does not have to make "fun" folk metal, such similarities to Finntroll or even Trollfest makes one expect that they will, especially considering the album cover has a dwarf flipping the bird to whoever may be taking his gold.

The music itself isn't bad; in fact there are many instances where it is excellent. The beginnings of "Ensam Ensling" or "Solens Ljus" are great ethereal sounding keyboard parts while "Vinterkvall" manages to balance between metal and keyboard very well. However, contrasting these examples are constant mundane chugging guitar riffs that have been played a thousand times before or riffs that start out well and simply either fail to evolve or do so into mediocrity. It seems as if at times Svartby is too ambitious, trying to use too many riffs in a song so that instead of having one or two good keyboard "folk" leads surrounding the vocals there instead are one or two good leads for about twenty seconds followed by two minutes of average sounding riffs thrown into the mix.

The keyboard leads that are present unfortunately still sound rather synthetic, which takes away from the mythical experience that Svartby are trying to create. Instead of thinking about dwarves riding frogs I'm stuck wondering why they chose to use such crummy synths for their album. Also, the vocals are extremely quiet in the mix, so it is impossible to understand a word they are saying. This is bad news for anyone looking to get a laugh out of their poor Swedish like in their past album, especially since they now use native Swedish speakers to proofread their lyrics before recording.

Riv, Hugg Och Bit could be a very good folk album, but the positive aspects are too often diluted by poor riffs and the vocals are almost a useless aspect of the album. Just remember that they have a new album coming out this year so anything could happen with it considering the potential of this album.

Performance: 8
Songwriting: 8
Originality: 7
Production: 9


Band profile: Svartby
Album: Riv, Hugg Och Bit


 


written by Marcus | 04.06.2010


Guest review disclaimer:
This is a guest review, which means it does not necessarily represent the point of view of the MS Staff.



Comments

‹‹ Back to the Reviews
Comments: 2  
Users visited: 24  
Search this topic:  


3dd - 09.06.2010 at 03:46  
The rating of this review is not the reality of this album, at all.
This masterpiece is one of best folk albums of all time in my opinion.
The synths are fucking awesome for this style and so the riffs, fun and cathy, and are not a problem like you said. You should give it another listen.
Marcus - 09.06.2010 at 08:00  
Written by 3dd on 09.06.2010 at 03:46

The rating of this review is not the reality of this album, at all.
This masterpiece is one of best folk albums of all time in my opinion.
The synths are fucking awesome for this style and so the riffs, fun and cathy, and are not a problem like you said. You should give it another listen.


I dunno man, I listened to the album probably 20 or so times and didn't find much of it fun or catchy, plus the synth heavy parts like in the 1st, 5th, 7th, and 9th songs are heavily inspired by Finntroll's Ur Jordens Djup, although Finntroll did a better job of it.

Opinions differ and I just didn't really dig this album and I wholeheartedly stand by my review.
(The rating may have been a little generous even )

Advertise on Metal Storm


Login or register to post here.



Similar topics

Forum Topic Similarity Started
Reviews Steve Vai - Passion And Warfare 4.5 22.05.2010 by
Reviews Bible Of The Devil - For The Love Of Thugs And Fools 2.5 04.05.2012 by Boxcar Willy
Reviews Estertor - Between Silence And Light 2.5 16.02.2009 by iaberis
News Alestorm - New Album Details And Song Online 1.5 28.03.2009 by WorpeX
News Hirax - Reveal New Album Title And Release Date 1.5 07.05.2013 by exomorphyx89



Hits total: 2384 | This month: 33