Yeah I've heard that album 4-5 times now and I still can't figure out what to rate it. The last time I remember having that much difficulty evaluating was the case of Enochian Theory's latest album. I oscillated between an 8 and a 9 and finally decided on 9, and I think that's what Eden Circus will experience as well.
As for Sumer, a strong competitor to Rishloo for alternative album of the year. Loving those clean vocals on the title track.