I know there are many other great singers out there, these are some of mine. If there's someone else please list them, I'm always willing to find new bands to love! Please feel free to say what you like, dislike about anything, everyone has an opinion.
My vote is for other: Olaf Hayer of Luca Turilli/Dionysus/Magic Kingdom dude has gotten better over the years was spectacular in Prophet of the Last Eclipse
Matt Barlow a close second since his voice is just tremendous albeit not the traditional power metal sound but definatley helped Iced Earth become what they are today
From that list I went with Matt Barlow, though I'd consider him more of a prog/thrash singer to be honest...then again, it's all interchangable, really.
Not from this list, definitely Kelly Sundown Carpenter. Never ceases to amaze me. I honestly have no idea why he's not more well known. His wikipedia page was even removed for the reason, quote, "non-notable singer, nothing special". That makes me sad. Glad he has finally joined Adagio permanently now. He has been touring them for years as a fill in when the band has had issues with previous singers leaving the country, etc. Can't wait to see what he does with them.
Blind Guardian is my one of my favourite bands, but how can you choose Hansi over Matt Barlow or Roy Khan? I cant understand... Matt has the best metal singing voice (next to Phil Anselmo and James Hetfield).
Gotta go with Hansi. He sounds unique. I love Matt Barlowe, but he says 'ah' after every sentence and though it's not too bad if you don't notice it, once you do, you hear it every time. I'm pretty sure he learned it from James Hetfield.
Fabio is an amazing singer, especially when he sings in his native language, but always amazing no matter what he does*. But I don't know if he's my favorite.
*except for this http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=txbTP5z2Z-M
I'm going to be predictable and say Daniel Heiman for number one. Listening to him is like sticking my penis in a light socket. In a good way.
Honorable mention to Russel Allen, Hansi, Toni Kakko, Ronnie James Dio (I'm putting him in here because was one of the best power metal singers regardless of whether or not what he sang was de facto power metal), Roy Khan, Jens Carlsson (Savage Circus, Dark Empire and Persuader, but for Savage Circus mostly), Marco Sandron** (Pathosray, but actually more for the most recent Fairyland album), Andre Matos, Eduardo Falaschi. Okay fine, Tobias Sammet, he's pretty awesome. And Kiske. And there could be more if I dipped into the power-prog category but the list is big enough.
What I just realized picking two big fistfuls of my favorite power metal singers is that I don't really love the singers as much as I love the performances that they have done. Singer + Music = A special sort of chemistry that transcends either alone. I don't really like Jens Carlsson for Persuader, although he clearly sounds good with them. Marco Sandron in Pathosray is the same, good but he wouldn't make the list for it. Kiske in Unisonic...eh not so much. Hansi in Demons And Wizards? Wouldn't make the cut. Russel Allen in Adrenaline Mob? Kakko in Northern Kings? Heiman is just not amazing in that band that he was in after Lost Horizon, I can't even remember and can't be bothered to google it. I seriously hope that Roy Khan gets into a good band where he can express his talent to its fullest again.
Okay I'm going to stop being a nobody on the internet dumping all over metal's finest for their side projects now
I have never understood Hansi Kürch's greatness. I think his voice is both hillarious and horrible. Me and my friends actually sometimes put on some Blind Guardian and have a laugh to how bad it is, especially the vocals.
"The Bro Code" article 72: A bro never spell-checks.
No one beats Hansi in my opinion. His vocals have a great balance between harsh aggression and dramatic theatricality that makes him so unique.
...And so death to the falsity of thy former rulers. Thy kingdom of "heaven" burns in a field of fire, and Dentura is the one true God thou must yield thy hearts and souls to in absolute submission. It is his ultimate decree and will unto thee..